Owning a historic home in Austin is a privilege—and a commitment that blends love for the past with a vision for the future. Whether you’ve fallen in love with a 1910s Craftsman in Hyde Park or a stately Victorian in Travis Heights, a common question arises: should you restore or renovate? While these terms are often used interchangeably, they have very different meanings, especially under Austin’s historic preservation guidelines. Understanding the implications of each can help you preserve your home’s character while meeting your family’s evolving needs.
This article is designed for homeowners, real estate investors, architects, and design-forward renovators in Austin who are seeking to improve, protect, or reimagine a historic property. You’ll learn the core differences between restoration and renovation, Austin-specific rules and incentives, and the most common missteps to avoid. Whether your goal is to increase resale value, honor the home’s original charm, or modernize it for everyday life, this guide offers the clarity and confidence you need to approach your project successfully.
Section 1: Why This Project Matters in Austin
Balancing Heritage and Modern Living in a Fast-Growing City
Austin’s rapid urban development continues to put pressure on preserving the city’s architectural identity. Historic neighborhoods like Clarksville, Pemberton Heights, and Old West Austin are protected not just for their aesthetic appeal, but for their deep-rooted contribution to the city’s cultural narrative. Homes in Local Historic Districts (LHDs) or designated as landmarks are part of a larger community legacy—and your remodeling choices directly impact that shared heritage.
Why your project matters:
- Renovating without permits can lead to costly fines, forced reversals, or frustrating project delays
- Restorative work may make you eligible for valuable state and local tax credits
- Maintaining architectural integrity preserves neighborhood cohesion and boosts long-term property values
- Thoughtful updates can contribute to the growing appeal of walkable, character-rich communities
As Austin continues to evolve, homeowners in historic areas are uniquely positioned to shape the future while preserving the past. This delicate balance makes every project an opportunity for civic contribution and personal pride.
Section 2: Common Design Trends or Upgrades
Trending Upgrades That Blend Comfort With Character
Historic homeowners in Austin seek improvements that meet modern living standards without erasing the home’s soul. The goal is harmony—between the functional and the faithful—so you enjoy all the benefits of new technology while honoring the home’s story.
Here’s what’s trending in 2025:
- Kitchen Restorations: Original cabinetry profiles, apron sinks, antique brass fixtures, butcher block or soapstone counters, and energy-efficient retro-style appliances
- Bathroom Enhancements: Subway and hex tile, clawfoot tubs, wainscoting, rain showers, traditional lighting mixed with high-efficiency plumbing
- Green Retrofits: Spray foam insulation, tankless water heaters, zoned HVAC systems, and solar panels hidden behind gables or landscaping that preserve curb appeal
- Outdoor Living: Restored porches with beadboard ceilings, custom millwork railings, reclaimed brick patios, pergolas, and landscaping with native plants that thrive in Austin’s climate
- Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs): Designed to match the primary structure’s facade with period-appropriate details and materials, often used for rental income or multigenerational living
In neighborhoods like North Loop or East Austin, you’ll find seamless integrations of industrial elements like steel and concrete with old-growth wood, period lighting, transom windows, and salvaged brick—proof that respecting history can still feel fresh and functional.
Section 3: Cost Breakdown in Austin
What to Expect When Budgeting for 2025
Historic remodeling requires more attention to detail, time, and skilled labor than standard upgrades. These complexities impact both timeline and cost. Here’s a breakdown based on recent Austin market data:
- Restoration of a Kitchen: $70K–$120K (includes custom woodwork, matching historic details, structural reinforcement, and custom finishes)
- Renovated Kitchen With Modern Layout: $55K–$90K (new materials and layout, fewer preservation requirements)
- Full Home Restoration: $250K–$500K for homes between 2,000–2,500 sq ft depending on the level of preservation and updates
- Exterior Restoration (Porch, Trim, Paint): $15K–$30K depending on materials, height, access, and detail level
Smart Ways to Save:
- Use the Texas Historic Preservation Tax Credit to recoup up to 25% of eligible expenses on approved projects
- Source reclaimed lumber and architectural salvage to maintain authenticity and reduce costs on hard-to-find pieces
- Stage your renovation in multiple phases to avoid cash-flow strain while keeping progress on track
- Choose a contractor who understands both design vision and code compliance—a combination that reduces surprises and improves ROI long-term
Section 4: Permits, HOA, or Zoning Considerations
Navigating Austin’s Complex Review Process
In Austin, working on a historically designated home goes beyond typical remodeling rules. External work requires a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) from the Historic Landmark Commission and sometimes even internal updates may fall under scrutiny—especially if they impact the visible structure.
What you’ll need to plan for:
- COA Approval: Required for any changes to roofing, siding, windows, porches, and exterior additions or demolitions
- Zoning Compliance: Limits on height, massing, and impervious cover still apply in historic districts, especially near water-sensitive zones
- HOA Restrictions: Neighborhoods like Tarrytown and West Lake Hills may impose additional design guidelines, material restrictions, or review boards
- Environmental Rules: Tree preservation ordinances, water runoff controls, and wildlife corridor restrictions may impact your exterior renovation or site plan
Start your permitting process with the City of Austin’s Historic Preservation Office and always consult with a preservation architect before beginning design.
Section 5: How to Choose the Right Contractor in Austin
Vetting Experts Who Understand Preservation
Not all contractors are created equal—especially when it comes to historic work. The right contractor won’t just build; they’ll navigate city regulations, preserve original details, and help you access cost-saving programs.
Ask these questions:
- Have you completed COA projects in Austin before?
- Can you provide photos or references from work in Hyde Park, Clarksville, Pemberton Heights, or similar districts?
- Are you familiar with tax credit documentation and historic material sourcing?
- Do you have an in-house design team or preservation specialist?
Avoid red flags like:
- Proposing vinyl windows or synthetic siding
- Skipping required permits or minimizing their importance
- Offering suspiciously low bids that omit crucial restoration steps
LIV180 works exclusively with Austin’s historic homes, guiding homeowners through each phase of the process—from drawings to doors, trim to tile, and compliance to comfort.
Section 6: Before and After Ideas / Case Study
Real-Life Restoration: 1920s Bungalow in Pemberton Heights
Before:
- Damaged porch overhang, broken wood trim, and boarded-up windows
- Galley-style kitchen with poor layout and deteriorated flooring
- Multiple non-original materials from previous remodels
After:
- Rebuilt front porch using reclaimed lumber and matching trim profiles
- Kitchen redesigned to maintain sightlines, feature a built-in breakfast nook, and showcase replica light fixtures
- Removed unsympathetic alterations and restored original window placements and flooring
Results:
- Received full COA approval in the first submission round
- Qualified for both local and state tax credits
- Appraisal increased by 28% post-renovation
- Home featured on local historic home tour
- Energy efficiency improved by 35% due to new insulation and HVAC
Call Now & Work With Us
Deciding between restoring and renovating doesn’t have to be confusing. With LIV180 by your side, you get expert design guidance, full permit support, and a team that understands Austin’s past and future. Whether your home needs a gentle touch or a complete transformation, we’re here to help you do it right. From layout reimagining to handcrafted restoration, we bring out the best in every square inch.
Call 561-235-9669 today to schedule a free consultation tailored to your historic home.
Contact Info
LIV180 Luxury Remodeling
Serving Austin, TX and surrounding areas
Call 561-235-9669
Schedule Your Free Consultation
https://form.jotform.com/LIV180/consultation
In partnership with Painter Bros of West Lake Hills
Azgari 
Leave a comment