Item 19 Explained: What a Franchise’s Earnings Disclosure Shows — and What It Leaves Out (2027)

franchise city alternative

Item 19 Explained: What a Franchise’s Earnings Disclosure Shows — and What It Leaves Out (2027)

Item 19 is the section of the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) headed “Financial Performance Representations.” It is the only place in the entire document where a franchisor is allowed to say anything about how much money its outlets make. If a salesperson, a broker, or a discovery-day slide deck gives you earnings numbers that are not in Item 19, those numbers are not supposed to exist — under the FTC Franchise Rule, a franchisor may only make financial performance claims inside Item 19.

The second thing to know is that Item 19 is optional. A franchisor that makes no earnings claims leaves the section essentially empty, and most do exactly that. Industry analyses by FRANdata have long put the share of franchisors that include a financial performance representation at roughly one in three. The other two in three hand you a document that is silent on the only question you care about most.

When an Item 19 does exist, it shows historical figures for some group of outlets, in a format the franchisor chooses. Usually that means gross sales. Sometimes it means gross margin. Rarely does it look like a full profit-and-loss statement. It never shows your future, your city, or your rent. The gap between what Item 19 shows and what it leaves out is where first-time buyers get hurt — so here is how to read both halves.

What Item 19 is allowed to contain

The FTC Franchise Rule sets the terms. Any financial performance representation must appear in Item 19, must have a reasonable basis when it is made, and the franchisor must hold written substantiation for it that a prospective buyer can ask to see. If the franchisor states a figure for a group of outlets, it must also state how many of those outlets actually achieved that figure — a detail many buyers never notice, and the first one worth checking.

Item 19 sits alongside two other items that matter just as much. Item 7 gives the franchisor’s estimated initial investment — the range of what it costs to open. Item 20 lists every current and former franchisee, with contact information for the current ones. Item 19 tells you what the franchisor wants you to believe about earnings. Item 20 hands you the phone numbers of the people who can tell you what they actually earned.

Five things to check in any Item 19

1. Who is counted. The figures may cover every outlet in the system, or only company-owned stores, or only franchised units open for three full years, or only the units that bothered to report. Each filter removes the weakest performers from the average. A system where half the units closed or never reported can still show a healthy “average” for the survivors.

2. What is counted. Gross sales are not income. Many Item 19 presentations stop at revenue, or at revenue minus a few cost lines. Labor, rent, insurance, loan payments, and your own salary are frequently below the cut. Royalties — around 8% of sales in the median franchise sample used in the comparison below — come out of your side of the ledger too.

3. The average versus the middle. An average can be pulled upward by a few star outlets. Look for the median, the range, and the percentage of outlets that reached the stated number. If the document gives you an average with no spread, treat the average as marketing, not evidence.

4. How old the numbers are. FDDs are updated once a year, so the figures describe a fiscal year that may have ended well over a year before you read them. A market that has since cooled, a road that has since closed, a competitor that has since opened — none of that is in the document.

5. What the subset quietly excludes. Outlets that closed during the year are generally not in the Item 19 group at all. Their story is told elsewhere — in the Item 20 tables that count openings, closures, and transfers. Read those tables. A brand can grow its outlet count while a steady stream of individual owners exits, and Item 19 alone will never show you that stream.

What Item 19 leaves out entirely

Even a complete, honest Item 19 cannot tell you what a specific territory will do. It does not know your rent, your local wage rates, your insurance costs, or the strength of the three competitors within two miles of the site you are considering. It does not show the bottom half of the system’s performers in any detail. And it says nothing about the experience of the people who already left — the former franchisees listed in Item 20, whose phone numbers the franchisor is required to leave reachable through the document’s own lists and who are usually the most candid witnesses you will find.

There is also a clock protecting you, if you use it. The franchisor must give you the FDD at least 14 calendar days before you sign anything or pay anything. Fourteen days is enough time to call twenty owners, if you spend it that way instead of spending it on the franchisor’s own tour.

A worked example: taking one Item 19 claim apart

To see how the five checks work together, take a claim of the kind Item 19s commonly make — the figures here are illustrative, assembled to show the reading method rather than taken from any one brand’s document. Suppose the section announces: “Average gross sales of $812,000 for franchised outlets in operation for the full year.” First question: how many outlets were in operation for the full year, and how many were excluded — opened mid-year, closed, transferred, or simply not reporting? If the system has 300 outlets and the average describes 190 of them, the missing 110 are part of the story. Second: how many of the 190 reached $812,000? The rule requires the franchisor to say; if the answer is 74, then the “average” outlet is a top-40% outlet, and the typical new owner should plan around the median, which the same document may place far lower. Third: what is below gross sales? At a royalty of roughly 8%, about $65,000 of that $812,000 leaves for the franchisor before rent, labor, supplies, insurance, or debt service are touched. Fourth: is there a second table breaking results into quartiles or by years in operation? Brands that publish quartiles are showing you the spread voluntarily; brands that publish only a mean are asking you not to ask. None of this arithmetic requires an accounting degree. It requires reading the section as a seller’s document — accurate where the rule forces accuracy, and silent exactly where silence is permitted.

The 4 ways to launch a business — compared honestly

Almost every first-time owner picks one of four doors. Here is what each one really costs, what you control, and what you keep — side by side.

Buy a franchise
Their brand, their rules
Cost to open
$265K–$573K
Royalties
✕ ~8% of sales
every year, ~10-year contract
Keep your job?
✕ Usually no
owner must work in it
Who runs year one
You
inside the franchisor’s rules
The brand
✕ Theirs
Buy an existing business
Someone else’s business
Cost to open
$350K median
Royalties
– $0
but loan payments start day one
Keep your job?
✕ Rarely
needs you full-time at once
Who runs year one
You
alone, from closing day
The brand
– The seller’s
their reputation comes with it
Start on your own
Every job is yours
Cost to open
Lowest cash in
Royalties
– $0
Keep your job?
✕ Rarely
nights & weekends until burnout
Who runs year one
You
alone — every mistake is yours
The brand
– Yours
built the slow, hard way
★ The fourth way
Launch with Azgari
Built for you, run for you
Cost to open
Under $265K, all-in
launch + the full first year
Royalties
✓ $0 — ever
Keep your job?
✓ Yes — that’s the point
Who runs year one
✓ Azgari runs it with you
The brand
✓ 100% yours
Why owners pick this one
Lowest all-in cost of the four, no royalties ever, an expert team running year one — and you keep your paycheck while it launches.

The honest risk note: about 78 of 100 new businesses make it past year one, and about half reach year five (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics). No path removes risk — which is exactly why the guidance matters. Franchise figures are medians from a 259-franchise-disclosure-document sample; existing-business price is the BizBuySell 2025 median; Azgari figures are Azgari’s own published terms.

Real stories

a worried business owner reviewing documents
Photo by KATRIN BOLOVTSOVA on Pexels.com

Kathy Wilkes believed the picture she was shown

Kathy Wilkes opened a Second Cup café in Stoney Creek, a suburb of Hamilton, Ontario, in early 2013. Within about two years she was out. Court documents put her café more than $165,000 in the red, and the company terminated her franchise agreement and took over the café. In its own filing, the company put her unpaid rent, royalties, and other fees at almost $92,000.

Wilkes sued. Her claim alleged, among other things, that the company had failed to disclose accurate information about the chain to her before she bought in — the exact failure Item 19 exists to prevent. The company rejected her allegations and countersued, accusing her of spreading false or defamatory information, so both sides’ versions were fought over in court rather than settled into agreed facts. What is not in dispute is the outcome: the café she bought was gone, the debts were real, and the information she says she relied on did not match the business she ended up owning. Her verdict, posted on the franchisee-warning page she founded, was blunt: “do not buy a Second Cup franchise!!” (The full account is in The Globe and Mail’s investigation of Second Cup’s franchisee revolt.)

Had Kathy Wilkes had a seasoned expert supporting them through launch, this could have had a different outcome.

Maxwell Nee’s most expensive lesson was skipping the expert

Maxwell Nee came to the same document problem from the investment side. Talking through the worst investment of his career on the My Worst Investment Ever podcast (Episode 643), the Brisbane-based investor in OENO Wine & Whisky Investment described going in as a first-timer without expert help — and named that, not the asset itself, as the core mistake. His conclusion, in his own words: “if you’re not an expert, your first time doing something, get a mentor, get a coach, or like, just just pay for it, just pay for an expert, if you can find one.”

That is the Item 19 lesson stated from the other side of the table. The document will not interpret itself, the averages will not flag their own exclusions, and the subset will not announce what it left out. Reading a disclosure document like an insider — or having someone beside you who already does — is the difference between the numbers as presented and the numbers as they are. (Hear Maxwell Nee’s episode of My Worst Investment Ever.)

Ready to see which path fits you?

Start with a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy personally. You leave with a written plan that tells you which path fits and what it will cost. The fee is credited toward your launch if you sign.

Book a Consultation

Want to see how it works first? Visit azgari.com — Azgari Business Launch and Management services. BBB A+ Rated · 5.0 from 11 BBB customer reviews.

Leave a Reply