Franchise or Independent? What One System’s 1,550 Buyers Actually Teach Us (2027)
Table of Contents
Franchise vs independent success rate is the question this story answers. Between 2015 and 2019, one burger chain, Burgerim, sold at least 1,550 franchises in the United States and collected at least $57.7 million in initial franchise fees — those are the findings of California’s Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, not a blogger’s tally. The overwhelming majority of those buyers never opened a restaurant. Here is what their documented experience shows about the franchise-versus-independent choice.
Pattern 1: The franchisor got paid; the buyers carried the risk
Franchise vs independent success rate starts with who gets paid first. Burgerim’s revenue came almost entirely from selling franchises, not from operating restaurants — about $45 million between 2016 and 2018, per the company’s own franchise documents as reported by Restaurant Business. Buyers typically paid $50,000–$70,000 for a first franchise. The leases, loans, and build-outs were theirs, signed for personally.
Robert Jameson, a buyer who managed to exit before his location was built, was still out $65,000 of his own money — the $50,000 fee plus $15,000 for the architect. His summary, given to Restaurant Business for its investigation, is the pattern in one quote: “The franchisee is the small guy. But they’re the ones who take on all of the risk. They have all of the contracts. And when something like this happens, they’re the ones left with the aftermath.”
Pattern 2: The promises were refundable; the refunds were not
Franchise vs independent success rate also turns on refunds. Burgerim told many buyers their fees were refundable if they could not find a location — a promise the FTC’s later complaint described as rarely honoured. Between 2017 and 2019, 287 franchisees cancelled their agreements and the company paid out roughly $8 million in refunds before, in Franchise Times’ account, the money ran out and cheques started bouncing. A promise is a marketing asset. A refund policy is only real if the money is escrowed or the company is solvent — which is why “where is my fee held until I open?” belongs on every buyer’s question list.
Pattern 3: Experience did not protect people; structure did
Franchise vs independent success rate does not follow experience. The buyers Restaurant Business interviewed were nurses, accountants, cooks, engineers, and educators. Some had restaurant experience; it did not save them, because the failure was not in their kitchens — it was in the franchisor’s finances. The buyers who limited their losses were the ones whose exposure was limited: Jameson, out before construction, lost $65,000. Buyers who signed leases and built out lost several times that. In the franchise structure, your diligence about the franchisor matters more than your competence at the trade, because the franchisor’s solvency is a term of your business whether you negotiated it or not.
Pattern 4: The system ended in enforcement, not recovery
Franchise vs independent success rate is written in enforcement records. The FTC and the Department of Justice sued in 2022 — the FTC’s first Franchise Rule enforcement action since 2007. California ordered nearly $4 million in fines and full restitution; a federal court entered a default judgment in 2024 with roughly $56 million in penalties and consumer redress and permanently banned the founder from selling franchises in the United States.
Regulators also reported difficulty finding substantial assets to enforce against. Winning the case, years later, is not the same as getting your money back. Prevention — the FDD, the validation calls, the escrow question — is the only remedy that arrives on time.
What the independent side of the comparison shows
No regulator keeps a registry of independent launches, which is exactly why this page will not invent a headcount for them. What can be priced is the structure. The trades Burgerim’s buyers wanted — food aside, the pattern repeats across home services — start independently at cleaning $500–$5,000 (Housecall Pro), handyman $1,100–$26,000, painting $1,200–$29,000, plumbing $10,000–$50,000 (the cost guides in our keyword research), with no royalty claim on gross sales and no franchisor whose solvency becomes your problem. The independent failure mode is ordinary — about half of new businesses close by year five (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics) — but it is your failure mode, at your scale, without a 10-year contract attached.
A franchise alternative gives you the launch help of a franchise — brand, website, systems, and coaching — without the franchise fee, the royalties, or giving up ownership of your own brand: that fourth structure exists precisely because the documented pattern above keeps repeating. The franchise vs independent success rate is the number this fourth structure is built to change.
Where a launch service fits
Franchise vs independent success rate is what a launch service changes. Azgari Business Launch and Management services is that fourth structure: the business designed with you, built under your own name — brand, website, booking systems, staffing — over 90–180 days, and managed through its first year while you keep your job. Flat fees of $20,000 / $40,000 / $60,000+ depending on scope, plus the business’s own startup costs; total, launch plus first year, under $265,000 all-in; $0 royalties, ever; the brand and customer list are 100% yours. It starts with a working session — one hour with Azgari Lipshy personally, a written plan, the $500 credited toward your launch if you sign.
The 4 ways to launch a business — compared honestly
Almost every first-time owner picks one of four doors. Here is what each one really costs, what you control, and what you keep — in plain numbers.
| What matters | 1. Buy a franchise | 2. Buy an existing business | 3. Start on your own | 4. Start independent — with Azgari as your guide |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost to get open | $265,000–$573,000 typical total investment | Median sale price $350,000, before working capital | Lowest cash in — but every beginner mistake comes out of your pocket | Under $265,000 total, all-in — launch plus the full first year |
| Ongoing fees | About 8% of gross sales in royalties and brand fees, every year, on a typical 10-year contract | No royalties — but loan payments and inherited costs start day one | No royalties | $0 royalties. Ever. |
| Whose brand is it? | The franchisor’s. You operate their name, their menu, their rules. | The previous owner’s — their reputation, good or bad, comes with it | 100% yours | 100% yours — your name, your brand, built for you |
| Control: prices, services, territory | The franchisor decides. And 85% of franchise agreements give you no exclusive territory at all. | Full control — over a business someone else designed | Full control, and full responsibility for every decision | Full control. You make the calls — Azgari does the work of building it. |
| Guidance | A proven system — that serves the franchisor first | None. After closing, you are on your own. | None. You learn everything the hard way. | An expert guide: Azgari designs it, builds it, staffs it, and manages the first year with you. |
| Can you keep your job? | Often no — many franchises require the owner working in the business, especially at the start | Rarely — an existing business usually needs you full-time from day one | Rarely — nights and weekends until it either works or burns you out | Yes — that is the point. Azgari runs year one while you keep your paycheck. |
| Time to open | Their timeline: training, build-out, approvals | Fastest — yours at closing, problems included | As long as it takes one person to figure out everything | 90–180 days, managed for you |
| When you are ready to sell | The sale usually needs franchisor approval, and the buyer is buying into their system — the brand equity is never fully yours | You can sell — at a value shaped by what you inherited | You can sell what you built | You sell a brand and business you own outright — every dollar of its value is yours. |
The honest risk note: about 78 of 100 new businesses make it past year one, and about half reach year five (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics). No path removes risk — which is exactly why the guidance matters. Franchise figures are medians from a 259-franchise-disclosure-document sample; existing-business price is the BizBuySell 2025 median; Azgari figures are Azgari’s own published terms. Compare franchise vs independent success rate before you choose a door.
Questions people ask about franchise vs independent outcomes
Is it better to start a business or buy a franchise? The documented evidence says the structure matters more than the slogan. In the Burgerim case — 1,550 franchises sold, at least $57.7 million in fees collected, per California regulators — the overwhelming majority of buyers never opened, because the franchisor’s business was selling franchises. A sound franchisor changes that maths; a fragile one makes your competence irrelevant. The FDD’s Items 3, 19, and 20 are how you tell the difference before signing.
Should you buy a business or start one from scratch? Buying an existing business (median sale price $350,000, per BizBuySell’s 2025 figures) buys immediate revenue and inherits its problems; starting from scratch costs less and builds exactly what you want, more slowly. The fourth option — starting independent with a launch service — exists for buyers who want the build handled without a franchise’s royalties or an acquisition’s inherited history.
What happens to franchisees when a franchisor collapses? They keep the leases, the loans, and the personal liability; the franchisor’s obligations become claims in enforcement actions that take years. In the Burgerim case, regulators ordered restitution and a federal court entered roughly $56 million in judgments in 2024 — while also reporting difficulty finding assets to enforce against.
Are franchise fees refundable? Only if the agreement says so, and only if the franchisor can pay. Burgerim promised refunds to buyers who could not find locations, paid roughly $8 million to 287 cancelling franchisees between 2017 and 2019, and then ran out of money. Ask where fees are held, and whether they are escrowed, before you sign.
How many Burgerim franchises were sold, and how many opened? At least 1,550 franchises sold between 2015 and 2019, collecting at least $57.7 million in initial franchise fees (California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation). Roughly 200 locations were open at the peak, and the overwhelming majority of buyers never opened a restaurant, per the FTC’s account.
Ready to see which path fits you?
Start with a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy personally. You leave with a written plan that tells you which path fits and what it will cost. The fee is credited toward your launch if you sign.
Want to see how it works first? Visit azgari.com — Azgari Business Launch and Management services. BBB A+ Rated · 5.0 from 11 BBB customer reviews.
Leave a Reply